What is the fastest way to reduce refunds without hurting CX?

Make exchange first the default with instant store credit and live inventory options. Customers swap instead of refunding and you keep the revenue.

Should I charge return fees?

Use smart fee logic. Keep free exchanges, charge for refunds on discretionary reasons, and waive fees for defects or wrong item. Show the policy clearly before checkout.

When is a returnless refund a good idea?

Use it for low value or non resellable items where shipping back costs more than the item. Guard with rules based on value, weight, and fraud risk.

How do I cut size and fit related returns?

Add detailed fit guides, customer photos, and size recommendations. Flag brand specific quirks like runs small or relaxed fit and show them on PDPs and in cart.

What tech stack helps automate returns and exchanges?

Use a returns portal connected to OMS, WMS, and payments to create RMAs, labels, and instant credit. Surface live inventory for one click exchanges.

Which KPIs prove the policy is working?

Refund vs exchange ratio, return rate by SKU and reason, time to exchange or resale, recovery rate, cost per return, and post return CSAT or NPS.

How does Transport Works help implement this?

We design the policy and flows, connect carriers and portals, set incentives and fee logic, build dashboards, and run pilots so you reduce refunds and keep more revenue.

Stop the Boomerang: Return-Policy Hacks That Keep Sales From Coming Back

Danyul Gleeson
Sep 4
5 min read

Updated: Sep 10

Peak season sales look glorious on spreadsheets - record traffic, carts maxed out, Slack channels lighting up with “we broke last year’s numbers!” But then comes January, the retail hangover. Instead of champagne corks, it’s packing tape screeching as a flood of “what was I thinking?” purchases boomerang right back.

It’s the winter migration of regret: sequined party dresses worn once and dropped, viral gadgets that didn’t live up to their unboxing, and “dupes” that turned out to be duds. In 2023, that migration cost U.S. retailers $743 billion - nearly 15% of sales swallowed by returns (NRF).

Here’s the kicker: most of it is preventable. The culprit isn’t just bad products - it’s return policies written like open-bar invites. Shoppers know they can over-order, “try out,” or impulse buy with no consequence.

The fix? Smart policy tweaks that set boundaries, steer behaviour, and still keep customers loyal. Think less “try-before-you-buy free-for-all,” more “buy smarter, stay longer.”

1. Shorter Return Windows for Peak Sales - Time Pressure Works Both Ways

Impulse buys are the heartbeat of Black Friday. The danger? They also become the lifeblood of January returns.

Restrict returns for peak season orders to shorter windows (e.g., 14–21 days vs the usual 30–60).
Extend longer windows only for exchanges or store credit. Customers keep shopping, you keep revenue.
Targeted brands using conditional windows cut return volumes by 10–20% post-holiday (Retail Dive).

Think of it as crowd control for your warehouse. The shorter the window, the fewer carts come rolling back in.

2. Charge for Return Shipping or Restocking - Free Isn’t Free

Here’s the math: free returns might look good in ads, but they’re burning holes in January balance sheets. Each return costs an average $25–$33 once you add shipping, labour, and restocking (Appriss/NRF).

Charge flat fees or tiered restocking charges for refunds only.
Keep exchanges and store credit free to nudge shoppers away from revenue-draining options.
Some retailers saw double-digit return drops after introducing modest fees, with only minor dips in conversion (McKinsey).

Consider it like adding a “cover charge” for refunds – serious buyers stay, impulse dabblers think twice.

3. Promote Exchanges & Store Credit - Don’t Let Cash Walk Out

Refunds are money leaving the building. Exchanges? That’s money still circulating in your ecosystem.

Default return options to exchange or store credit.
Add perks: bonus credit, free shipping on the replacement, or limited-time upsells.
Customers offered credit or exchanges are 30% more likely to purchase again compared to refund seekers (Invesp).

It’s retail judo – using the shopper’s momentum to keep them moving with your brand, not away from it.

4. Restrict Returns on Discounted or Final-Sale Items - Doorbusters Shouldn’t Boomerang

Peak sales often mean doorbusters and fire-sale pricing. If you’re selling $20 headphones at 70% off, don’t expect to absorb a wave of no-questions-asked returns.

Make deeply discounted, clearance, or flash-sale items final sale.
Alternatively, restrict refund eligibility but still allow exchanges.
Be upfront: communicate restrictions clearly on product pages and at checkout.

Shoppers respect clarity more than “surprise gotchas.” The clearer the terms, the fewer angry post-peak emails.

5. Provide Better Product Info & Pre-Return Support - Fix Before the Box Ships Back

A huge portion of returns are preventable – wrong size, unclear specs, confusing descriptions.

Invest in detailed sizing guides, 360° product images, and real customer reviews.
Offer live chat or pre-return troubleshooting – often customers just need reassurance or a quick fix.
Brands that improved product descriptions and fit guidance saw return rates fall by 20–30% in apparel alone (Fit Analytics, Shopify+).

Think of it as customer triage – solve the issue before the RMA form ever gets filled.

Policy Tweaks That Work: Quick Reference

Policy Change	Return Reduction Impact	Best For
Shorter return window (peak season)	High – discourages impulse returns	Black Friday / holiday orders
Final sale / restricted returns	High – cuts volume on discounted items	Doorbusters & clearance
Paid returns (refunds only)	High – deters non-serious buyers	All peak orders
Enhanced product info & support	Medium to high – reduces preventable returns	Apparel, electronics
Exchanges & credit incentives	Medium – retains revenue & loyalty	General merchandise

FAQs: Return-Policy Tweaks That Reduce Post-Peak Chaos

Do shorter return windows actually reduce post-peak returns?

Yes - and fast. Retailers who tightened return windows during peak sales saw 10–20% fewer January returns (Retail Dive). Shorter deadlines discourage impulse purchases, while offering extended windows for exchanges or store credit keeps customers engaged without draining revenue.

Should retailers charge for returns to cut volumes?

Charging a modest fee for refund returns works - average returns cost $25–$33 per order once shipping, labour, and restocking are included (Appriss/NRF). Many retailers now make refund returns paid while keeping exchanges and credits free, shifting behaviour without scaring off loyal customers.

Why promote exchanges and store credit instead of refunds?

Because refunds are revenue leaving the room. Exchanges and credits keep money circulating inside your brand. Invesp found that customers offered store credit are 30% more likely to purchase again than refund seekers. Add perks like free shipping or bonus credit, and you’ll boost loyalty while slashing refunds.

Do final sale or discounted items need stricter return rules?

Absolutely. Doorbusters and 70%-off “flash deals” are notorious return drivers. Making steep discounts final sale or limiting their return eligibility sets clear expectations up front. Retailers that did this cut post-peak returns on promo items by over 25% (Forbes Retail). Transparency at checkout is key - no hidden fine print.

How does better product info reduce return rates?

Most returns aren’t fraud - they’re preventable mistakes. Wrong size, unclear specs, or misleading photos. When retailers added detailed sizing guides, realistic images, and verified reviews, apparel returns alone dropped by 20–30% (Shopify+ / Fit Analytics). Pair with live chat support to catch issues before the RMA form ever gets filled.

Exit Scan: Smarter Policies, Smoother January

Returns are inevitable – but chaos isn’t. With shorter windows, restricted discounts, smarter fees, better info, and a strong push toward exchanges, you transform January from “warehouse regret month” into “revenue recovery month.”

The result? Lower costs, faster inventory flow, and customers who know what to expect - and respect you more for it.

At Transport Works, we don’t just ship boxes - we design policies and flows that make sure they don’t come flying back. Because Always Delivering doesn’t just mean getting orders out the door - it means making sure they don’t all boomerang straight back in.

Let's Chat

Insights from Danyul Gleeson, Founder & Chaos Tamer-in-Chief at Transport Works

Danyul has been in the trenches - warehouses where pick paths were sketched on pizza boxes and boardrooms where the “supply chain strategy” was a shrug. He built Transport Works to flip that script: a 4PL that turns broken systems into competitive advantage. His mission? Always Delivering - without the chaos.